Introduction

At Offbeat Concerns (OBC), fact-checking is a systematic process of identifying potentially misleading information, tracing its origin, examining evidence and independently verifying claims.

Our work is guided by accuracy, independence, transparency, fairness and accountability. We assess claims based on available evidence, irrespective of their source, political affiliation or popularity.

1. Claim Selection

OBC monitors social media platforms, messaging applications, digital publications and other online sources to identify potentially false, misleading or manipulated information.

Claims are prioritised based on:

  • Virality: The speed and extent of their circulation.
  • Public interest: Their relevance to elections, public health, conflicts, communal tensions, government policies and other significant issues.
  • Potential harm: Their capacity to incite hostility, cause harm, damage reputations or influence public behaviour.
  • Influential sources: Verifiable assertions from public officials, politicians, media organisations, and prominent online accounts.
  • Emerging narratives: Recurring misinformation, coordinated campaigns and audience submissions.

We generally do not fact-check pure opinions, personal beliefs, clearly identifiable satire or unverifiable predictions. Where a statement combines opinion with factual assertions, we isolate the verifiable component.

2. Evidence Preservation and Source Tracing

Before investigating a claim, we preserve available evidence, including original URLs, screenshots, post IDs, images, videos, captions, timestamps, transcripts and relevant metadata.

We attempt to identify the earliest available instance of the content, its publisher, publication date and previous circulation across platforms.

The earliest identifiable instance is not automatically considered the original source. We distinguish between the earliest available evidence and the proven origin of a claim.

3. Verification and Investigation

OBC uses a combination of primary-source research, open-source intelligence (OSINT), digital forensics and independent corroboration, depending on the nature of the claim.

Primary sources and expert consultation: We prioritise original documents, government records, court proceedings, official datasets, institutional statements, research papers and other relevant primary material. Independent subject-matter experts may be consulted to interpret specialised claims.

OSINT verification: Our investigations may employ:

  • Reverse image and video searches to identify original publications, earlier appearances and recycled content.
  • Video analysis, including keyframes, visual indicators, audio and upload history.
  • Geolocation using landmarks, buildings, roads, signboards, maps and satellite imagery.
  • Chronolocation using weather, shadows, seasonal indicators, historical imagery and other time-related evidence.
  • Metadata examination, recognising that metadata can be removed, modified or fabricated.
  • Satellite and geospatial analysis to investigate claims related to conflicts, military activity, infrastructure, disasters, and territorial developments.

Digital forensics and AI-generated content: We examine images, videos and audio for possible manipulation or synthetic generation through visual analysis, frame examination, audio analysis, source tracing and comparison with authentic material. AI detection tools may assist investigations but are never treated as conclusive evidence on their own.

Context verification: Authentic content can be misleading when presented out of context. We examine the original circumstances, date, location and context in which material was created and circulated.

Independent corroboration: Important findings are cross-checked against reliable sources. We assess source credibility, independence, proximity to the original evidence and possible contradictions.

Where appropriate, we contact relevant individuals, institutions, authorities, experts or eyewitnesses for clarification. A failure to receive a response does not establish that a claim is false.

4. Evidence Assessment and Verdicts

We assess the available evidence collectively, considering its quality, reliability, independence, consistency and relevance to the claim.

We distinguish facts from indications, assumptions and unresolved questions. Where evidence is insufficient, we acknowledge uncertainty rather than presenting speculation as fact.

OBC uses the following verdict classifications:

VerdictDefinition
TrueSupported by reliable evidence and materially accurate.
FalseContradicted by credible and sufficient evidence.
MisleadingAccurate information presented in a way that creates a false impression.
Missing ContextAuthentic or substantially accurate material presented without important context.
Partly FalseContains both accurate and inaccurate elements.
UnverifiedInsufficient evidence to establish the claim’s accuracy.
Satire/ParodyContent presented as humour or satire rather than a factual assertion.
FakeContent that has been digitally manipulated, morphed or altered.
AI-generatedContent created using artificial intelligence.

Verdicts reflect the evidence available at the time of publication.

5. Writing and Editorial Review

OBC fact-checks present the original claim, its context, the investigation, supporting evidence, findings, sources and final verdict.

We provide links to original posts, primary documents, official records, datasets and other relevant evidence wherever possible.

Before publication, fact-checks undergo editorial review to assess factual accuracy, evidence quality, source reliability, attribution, context, verdict consistency, language and potential conflicts of interest.

The conclusion must be supported by the evidence presented.

6. Independence and Ethics

OBC’s fact-checking decisions are independent of political parties, governments, advertisers and other external interests.

Team members must disclose relevant conflicts of interest. Investigations may be reassigned or conflicts disclosed where necessary to protect editorial independence.

Our work follows these principles:

  • Accuracy over speed: Being first is less important than being correct.
  • Evidence over assumption: Initial hypotheses must not determine conclusions.
  • Transparency over certainty: Uncertainty must be acknowledged.
  • Fairness: Relevant parties should receive a reasonable opportunity to respond.
  • Accountability: Errors must be corrected transparently.

7. Corrections and Updates

Fact-checks may be updated when new evidence emerges, or errors are identified. Depending on their significance, corrections may involve revising the article, adding an editorial note, changing the verdict or correcting associated headlines and social media posts.

Material changes are clearly indicated. Significant corrections are never silently concealed.

8. Investigative Fact-Checking

OBC recognises that misinformation can extend beyond individual posts or isolated incidents. Some investigations therefore examine the wider information ecosystem through:

  • Social media account networks and coordinated amplification.
  • Recurring misinformation narratives and hashtag campaigns.
  • Cross-platform dissemination and recycled content.
  • Impersonation and manipulated or synthetic media.
  • Sources repeatedly associated with the spread of misinformation.

We distinguish documented evidence from analytical interpretation. An account or individual is not labelled a source of misinformation solely because they have shared an inaccurate claim. Broader assessments require sufficient evidence and context.

Our Commitment

Our objective is to establish what can be demonstrated through available evidence, not to advance a political or ideological position.

OBC remains committed to independent verification, transparent reporting, acknowledging uncertainty and correcting errors. Our methodology will evolve alongside technology and misinformation tactics, while our commitment to accuracy and accountability remains unchanged.