Sonia Gandhi’s Memoir: Two Viral Claims, Two False Narratives 

Sonia Gandhi’s Memoir: Two Viral Claims, Two False Narratives 

As Sonia Gandhi’s memoir sparks a political storm, two viral claims have added to the online chatter. But are unsold copies being dumped on Mumbai streets, and does a viral photo reveal a moment missing from her book? OBC digs deeper. 

The release of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, has triggered a massive political storm and a widespread wave of social media misinformation.

On the political front, Shiv Sena leaders tore pages from the book in Mumbai in response to her remarks on Savarkar. At the same time, the BJP accused her of whitewashing the Nehru-Gandhi family’s record. Meanwhile, numerous social media posts have been circulated online alongside the book release, including a viral video falsely depicting a roadside bookseller in Mumbai’s Fort area claiming unsold copies were dumped on him and a separate image purporting to show Gandhi seated on an elderly man’s lap, with claims that she omitted the moment from her book. 

OBC has identified these claims as false.

What are the viral posts?

Are copies of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir unsold in Mumbai?

On 15 November, X user Janardan Mishra posted a video showing Sonia Gandhi’s memoir being sold at a roadside stall in Mumbai. The post is captioned, “Congress workers sold Sonia Gandhi’s new book, which was given to them to distribute, at the old book market on the sidewalk in Mumbai’s Fort area, and the scrap dealer says no one is even buying it anymore. Those days are gone for them now .”

Screenshot of the X posts shared on 15 November.

The post has attracted over 314k views and 2k likes on the platform, as of 19 November.

Numerous other X accounts have shared similar videos. The X account Megh Updates also shared the same video with the caption, “A viral video from Mumbai’s Fort area claims that copies of Sonia Gandhi’s new book, reportedly distributed among Congress workers, have ended up for sale at a roadside second-hand book market. Even more embarrassing, the bookseller claims that nobody is willing to buy them! If true, Congress has a rather awkward question to answer: Were these books distributed to be read or simply to fulfil a formality? ”

Screenshot of the X posts shared on 15 November.

As of 19 November, the post had garnered over 101k views and 4.3k likes. 

Many user comments were satirical, while others were communal, with users making derogatory statements about Muslims in India. One user commented, “if only it was written in Urdu, all namazis would have bought it.” Another user remarked, “These books can be best used by roadside Bhel Puri Vendor…!! .”

We examined the viral video closely and identified numerous discrepancies.  Upon closer inspection, it became clear that the background is unusually quiet for a busy street, the cover lettering turns garbled when the vendor lifts the book toward the camera, and most of the other books have no legible text. Near the end, the man and the vendor appear to speak in the same voice. 

 We used digital detection tools to determine whether the footage was AI-generated. 

Screenshot of AI detection analysis.

The results estimated a 91.8% likelihood of AI-generated speech and a 66.8% likelihood of AI-generated video content.

Screenshot of the viral post showing the watermark.

In the video, we noticed a watermark in the lower right-hand corner written in Hindi, which translates to English as “Ajith Neethi.”

For additional context, we conducted a reverse image search using keyframes from the video, which led us to the original post. The video was uploaded on November 12 by a Facebook account named Ajith Nithi. The video also appears to have an AI-generated tag.

Screenshot of the Facebook post shared on 12 November.

According to a report by The Hindu, Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, sold over two lakh copies in less than a week. At the book launch in New Delhi on November 16, HarperCollins India CEO Ananth Padmanabhan said it broke multiple sales records, becoming the fastest-selling debut non-fiction work and memoir in the publisher’s history, with more than 15,000 copies delivered within just 10 minutes of release.

Did Sonia Gandhi sit on an elderly man’s lap?

An X user named Manoj Srivastava posted this video on X on 13 November, with the caption, “**In Antonio’s book* *There’s no mention of this chair*”

Screenshot of the X post shared on 13 November.

As of 19 November, the photo has amassed over 4k views and more than 350 likes.

A Facebook user named Sanjay Agrawal posted the same photo with a caption in Hindi that translates to, “Rajmata is worried that this donkey may also make the name of the real father public.”

Screenshot of the Facebook posts shared on 19 November.

The photo has received 435 likes and 103 shares as of 19 November.

Many of the comments under the post are sarcastic. One user commented, “This is original Sonia belonging of love,” while another stated, “OMG! Bharat ki bahu? I am ashamed!”

Our analysis of the viral post and subsequent deep-dive search found that numerous right-wing groups in India have shared similar videos with misleading captions over the past few years.

Screenshots of older viral social media posts from past years.

We analysed the viral post and searched official records and credible news reports to verify the claim. We found official news records confirming that the then President of the Republic of Maldives, Maumoon Abdul Gayoom, visited India from March 27 to April 1, 2005. At the time, Sonia Gandhi was the president of the Congress party and chairperson of the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA).

Screenshot of the news article from the Government of India.

Additionally, we conducted a reverse image search using keyframes from the viral video, which led us to the original picture of the visit from the AFP Forum.

Screenshot of the original photo from AFP.

Therefore, the viral picture is digitally manipulated.

OBC’s analysis found that posts claiming to show a Mumbai roadside stall selling unsold copies of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging, are misleading. The video clip’s watermark traces it to a Facebook account that posted it on November 12 with an AI-generated tag. 

Similarly, the photo claiming to show Gandhi seated on an elderly man’s lap is also false: a reverse image search led to an AFP photograph from a 2005 visit by the then Maldivian President Maumoon Abdul Gayoom, in which Gandhi was not seated on anyone’s lap. Therefore, both viral claims about the memoir are false.

Khadeeja Saniyya

Khadeeja Saniyya

Khadeeja Saniyya is a Journalist at OBC

View all posts by Khadeeja Saniyya
Share Email
Top